top of page

Your Employees May Not Need More. They May Need Less Getting in Their Way.

May 27
5 min read

Updated: Sep 7

When employees are frustrated, disengaged, or beginning to leave, leadership often starts with a reasonable question:


What more can we provide?


The answer might be better benefits, a recognition program, new wellness resources, a team event, additional training, or another tool intended to improve the employee experience.

None of those things is inherently superficial or misguided. Employees can genuinely value them. Recognition matters. Useful benefits matter. Development matters. Time together can matter.

But an addition cannot resolve a separate condition that is making the work unnecessarily difficult.


An employee may appreciate being recognized and still spend each day correcting incomplete handoffs.


A company may provide paid time off while workloads or management expectations make employees reluctant to use it.


A wellness resource may be available while unpredictable schedules, constant urgency, or work spilling into personal time continue to limit recovery.


The benefit exists. The original strain also exists.


An addition is not the same as a foundation


Workplace programs often sit on top of the daily working environment. They may improve something around the work without changing how the work itself functions. That distinction matters.


A recognition program may help employees feel noticed, but it cannot clarify responsibilities that remain poorly defined.


A communication platform may make information easier to send, but it cannot determine who owns the next step.


A new benefit may provide meaningful support, but it cannot guarantee that employees can access or use it without creating additional pressure elsewhere.


A team event may strengthen relationships, but it cannot correct an uneven workload that repeatedly places the same people under strain.


The addition may still be worthwhile. It simply should not be expected to solve a condition it was never designed to address.


Providing something does not prove that it works in practice


Leadership often sees the formal version of a workplace structure.

The policy was approved. The resource was funded. The program was announced. The tool was purchased. From that perspective, the organization provided what employees were supposed to need.


Employees experience the functional version:


Can the policy be used as intended?


Can the resource be accessed when it is needed?


Does the tool support the way the work is actually performed?


Does the program address what matters to the people in those roles?


The gap between provision and function is where a well intended investment can lose its value.

Paid time off is a healthy workplace feature. But if using it causes a backlog, creates guilt, or draws resistance from a manager, the benefit does not function as intended.

Development opportunities are valuable. But if employees do not understand how people are selected, or access is distributed inconsistently, the opportunity may not provide a credible path forward.

Training can improve clarity and performance. But if the material is outdated, difficult to locate, or disconnected from the employee’s actual responsibilities, the existence of training does not resolve the underlying confusion.


A workplace structure creates value when the people relying on it can access it, use it, and receive the benefit it was intended to provide.


Why more is not always the answer


When an initiative fails to improve retention or daily work, leadership may understandably conclude that employees are difficult to satisfy.

The company provided a benefit, invested in a program, or made an effort to show appreciation. Yet the same concerns remain.

That can create frustration on both sides.


Leadership may feel that employees always want something else. Employees may feel that the conditions affecting them are being overlooked. Each response can reinforce the other until a practical workplace problem becomes a broader trust problem.


The missing step is often diagnosis.


The organization may not need another companywide initiative. It may need to determine why an existing policy is not reaching employees, why a particular handoff keeps failing, why responsibilities repeatedly move toward the same reliable people, or why a schedule that appears reasonable on paper cannot be relied upon in practice.

Some findings may require a meaningful financial investment. Compensation may be insufficient. Staffing may not match the work. Equipment may need to be replaced.


Other findings may point to a smaller correction:


  • An employee needs access that should already have been provided.


  • A manager needs clearer authority to approve time away.


  • A process needs one defined owner.


  • A recurring meeting no longer serves a useful purpose.


  • A schedule needs to be released earlier.


  • Training needs to reflect the work people are currently doing.


  • Work needs to stop reaching employees during protected personal time.


The goal is not to assume every workplace problem has an inexpensive solution. It is to understand the problem well enough that the organization is not spending against the wrong assumption.


The research supports looking beyond individual programs


A 2024 University of Oxford study examined survey data from 46,336 employees across 233 organizations. The study found no evidence that participants in several common individual level wellbeing interventions, including mindfulness, resilience training, stress management, and wellbeing apps, had better subjective wellbeing than nonparticipants. The researcher concluded that organizational changes involving scheduling, management practices, staffing resources, performance review, or job design may play a greater role in workplace wellbeing. The University of Oxford’s Wellbeing Research Centre explains the findings here. [wellbeing....c.ox.ac.uk], [onlinelibr....wiley.com]


That does not prove wellness programs have no value. The study evaluated particular individual level interventions within a specific dataset, and its findings should not be stretched into a universal conclusion.


It does support an important distinction:

Helping employees manage strain is not the same as identifying and reducing the workplace conditions producing it.

Gallup’s research has also connected workplace conditions and employee engagement with business outcomes that include productivity, turnover, absenteeism, safety incidents, and quality defects. Gallup’s Q12 research provides the underlying business outcome findings.


Broad research can show that workplace conditions matter. The organization still needs to determine which conditions matter here.


Remove the roadblock before adding another destination


Redthorne does not begin by assuming employees need more perks, more programs, or more motivation. We begin by asking whether something is unnecessarily getting in their way.


That may include a missing workplace feature. It may also involve a policy that exists but cannot be used, a process that creates repeated rework, a role that no longer aligns with the work, or a management practice that functions differently in reality than it does on paper.

The purpose is not to strip away the extras employees appreciate. It is to make sure those extras are resting on a workplace foundation that functions.


Before investing in another solution, leadership deserves to know whether the organization needs something new or whether its people simply need less avoidable strain standing between them and the work they are already trying to do.

Find what is getting in your people’s way


The Organizational Stability Assessment identifies if and where workplace conditions are creating strain, traces that strain to its root causes, and shows leadership how it is affecting work and retention.


Sources and Further Reading





Recent Posts

See All
A Stable Result Is Still a Result

Finding little meaningful strain is not an empty outcome. It provides evidence of what is working, what leadership should protect, and whether the organization may qualify for the Redthorne Business S

 
 
 
Why Growth Makes a Business Harder to Read

As a company grows, information passes through more roles, priorities, and relationships before reaching leadership. The business can outgrow the informal ways its leaders once understood what was hap

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page