top of page

Why Growth Makes a Business Harder to Read

Oct 5
8 min read

In the early days of a business, information travels differently.


The owners know the employees. Questions reach the people who can answer them. A conversation in the hallway can reveal that a process is not working. Leadership can notice when someone is unusually overloaded or when a small problem keeps returning.


The organization does not need an elaborate system to understand itself because the people making decisions remain close to the work.


Then the business grows.

More employees join. Responsibilities become specialized. Managers coordinate teams. Departments develop their own priorities. Formal systems replace informal conversations.

These changes are necessary. They allow the company to operate beyond the direct reach of its founders.


They also change how leadership learns what is happening.

The business has not necessarily become less honest or less healthy. It has become harder to read.


Growth increases the distance information must travel


A growing company needs structure.

Employees cannot all report directly to the owner. Every operational question cannot become an executive decision. Managers need authority to handle daily concerns, coordinate responsibilities, and protect leadership’s attention for matters requiring higher level involvement.


That structure makes growth possible. It also means workplace information passes through more people before reaching someone with the authority to make a broader change.


An employee notices that incomplete handoffs require repeated rework.


The employee raises the concern with a supervisor.


The supervisor recognizes the difficulty but sees it as part of a broader workload problem.


The workload concern reaches a department leader as a request for additional capacity.


Leadership hears that the department may need another employee.


Nobody involved necessarily misrepresented the situation. Each person translated the information according to the responsibilities and context available at that level.


But the original condition changed as it traveled.

What began as a specific handoff problem arrived as a staffing question.

If leadership adds staff without seeing the original mechanism, the organization may increase capacity while preserving the same rework.


Information is filtered by relevance


People do not pass every detail upward.

They decide which information matters to the next person, how urgent it is, and whether it deserves attention alongside everything else competing for time.


This filtering is often useful.

Executives should not need to review every scheduling adjustment, software issue, workflow question, or interpersonal concern occurring across the company. Managers are expected to interpret what is happening and decide what needs escalation.

The difficulty appears when a detail that seems small at one level is part of a larger pattern elsewhere.


One employee encountering a temporary workaround may not require executive attention.


Several teams relying on similar workarounds may indicate that an organizational system is no longer supporting the work.


A manager may know what is happening inside one team without knowing that another department is reporting a related concern.


Each local view may look manageable. The combined pattern may tell a different story. Leadership needs aggregation, but aggregation can remove the context that explains why the problem exists.


Hierarchy can change the information that reaches the top


Organizational hierarchy is not inherently a problem. It establishes responsibility, decision authority, and coordination.

Research nevertheless shows that hierarchy can influence how information is produced and transmitted.

A study published in The Review of Financial Studies examined a reorganization affecting roughly 2,000 bank branches in India. The researchers found evidence that valuable local information may be lost within more hierarchical structures, although the study also identified circumstances in which hierarchy provided benefits. Research from Oxford Academic examines how organizational hierarchy can affect information production and decision making. [academic.oup.com]


Research into communication patterns at Microsoft has likewise examined how routine communication develops within and across supervisory hierarchies. The researchers found distinct communication structures between teams and emphasized the importance of a person’s position within the hierarchy. The research paper on communication dynamics in a large organizational hierarchy is available here. [arxiv.org]


These studies do not prove that every growing company loses important information or that fewer leadership levels are always better.

They support a more measured conclusion:

Organizational structure affects how information moves.


As the structure becomes more complex, leadership cannot assume that the information arriving at the top contains every detail needed to understand conditions at the level where work is performed.


Everyone has something they are trying to protect


Information is not filtered only because of hierarchy.

People also consider what might happen after they speak.


Employees may protect:

  • Their livelihoods

  • Working relationships

  • Future opportunities

  • Their standing with a manager

  • The cohesion of the team

  • Their personal energy

  • The peace around them

Managers may protect:

  • Their employees

  • Their credibility

  • Their relationship with leadership

  • The team’s ability to keep operating

  • The organization from another disruption

  • Leadership from a concern that seems manageable locally

Executives may protect:

  • Organizational stability

  • Client commitments

  • Financial resources

  • Strategic priorities

  • The managers trusted to carry the business forward

These interests are not evidence that one side is behaving dishonestly.

They are part of the practical reality of working inside an organization.

People weigh the value of sharing a concern against the possible consequences of raising it.


Sometimes speaking seems useful.

Sometimes remaining quiet feels safer.


Silence is not always agreement


A lack of complaints can be reassuring.

It can also mean that the available reporting channels do not feel appropriate for the concern.


A 2024 systematic review of research on workplace silence distinguished individual employee silence from broader organizational silence. The review found that both are shaped by contextual conditions and leadership, and that silence can affect individual and organizational outcomes. The review published by Emerald examines what research has established about silence in the workplace. [emerald.com]


That does not mean every quiet employee is withholding an important problem. Silence may reflect satisfaction, focus, uncertainty, fatigue, personal preference, or a belief that the issue does not deserve escalation.

The point is that silence cannot be interpreted confidently from the outside.

An employee may remain quiet because the condition is tolerable.

Another may remain quiet because previous attempts did not lead anywhere.

Someone else may worry that the details will reveal who raised the concern.

Leadership cannot determine which explanation applies without a safer and more structured way to gather information.


An open door does not remove every barrier


Many leaders genuinely want employees to raise concerns.

They communicate an open door policy. They invite questions. They tell employees that feedback is welcome.


Those efforts matter.

They do not remove every reason someone may hesitate.

The employee may respect the leader and still worry about bypassing a manager.


The concern may involve the person who would normally receive it.

The employee may not know whether the issue is important enough to escalate.

The problem may be difficult to explain without naming coworkers or revealing personal details.

The employee may have identified a symptom without understanding its organizational cause.

An open door creates availability.

It does not automatically create the safety, structure, or context required for every concern to reach leadership clearly.


More communication does not always create more clarity


When leaders sense a visibility problem, a natural response is to increase communication. The organization adds meetings, dashboards, surveys, check ins, reports, and updates.


These tools may improve visibility.

They may also increase the amount of information without improving the quality of what leadership understands.


A dashboard can show that productivity declined. It may not explain whether the cause is workload, rework, delayed approvals, unreliable technology, unclear responsibilities, or another condition.


A meeting can give employees a place to speak. It may not provide enough protection for someone to raise a sensitive concern in front of managers or coworkers.


A survey can produce an engagement score. It may not show what is contributing to that score or how the condition enters daily work.


The goal is not merely to make more information travel upward.

Leadership needs information that retains enough context to support an accurate decision.


Growth creates connections that are harder to see locally


As an organization expands, workplace conditions become more interconnected.


A scheduling practice may appear manageable within one department but create attendance pressure elsewhere.


A process change may improve speed for one team while shifting administrative work to another.


A new approval requirement may strengthen control while delaying customer work.


A manager may appear to have a workload problem when employees are actually absorbing responsibilities that lack clear ownership.


Each condition can look different depending on where someone stands.

This is why direct observation becomes less reliable as the business grows.

Leadership may still walk the floor, attend meetings, and maintain relationships with employees. Those efforts provide valuable information.

But no executive can personally experience every role, shift, system, management relationship, or process transition inside a growing organization.

The company needs a way to bring those perspectives together without turning every employee concern into an individual complaint.


Independent participation creates a different route


Redthorne does not replace managers, leadership conversations, or internal reporting channels.


The Organizational Stability Assessment creates an additional route.

Employees participate through an independently administered process. The guided structure helps employees identify relevant workplace conditions without requiring them to write a complaint, diagnose the organization, or directly accuse another person.


Individual responses remain private.

Leadership receives combined findings that clarify where the organization appears stable and where workplace conditions may be creating strain.

This separation matters because the employee does not have to carry the concern personally into the leadership structure.


The assessment also allows related conditions to be viewed together.

Leadership can see whether an issue appears isolated, whether a broader pattern is developing, and whether the condition has meaningful consequences for the organization.


The purpose is not to bypass managers or undermine the leadership structure.

It is to give the organization access to information that may not travel clearly through ordinary reporting relationships.


Better visibility does not take control away from leadership

Understanding the organization more clearly does not require leadership to surrender control over what happens next.

Redthorne identifies and translates the findings.


Leadership decides:

  • Which areas deserve attention

  • Which recommendations fit the business

  • What resources are available

  • Whether a change is practical

  • Who should be involved

  • How implementation should occur

  • What timing makes sense

The assessment may confirm that an existing structure is working.


It may show that a concern is limited rather than organization wide.


It may identify a practical obstruction leadership can address internally.

It may reveal a condition requiring a larger investment or specialized expertise.

The evidence informs the decision.

It does not replace leadership’s judgment.


The goal is not to remove organizational layers


A growing company does not need to return to the days when every employee spoke directly with the founder. Leadership layers exist for a reason. Managers provide coordination, context, support, and decision capacity the organization needs. The goal is not to flatten every hierarchy or route every concern around management. Instead, the goal is to recognize that the business now requires a more dependable way to understand itself.

The informal methods that worked when the company was smaller may not provide enough visibility at its current scale.

That is not a leadership failure.

It is a natural point in organizational growth.


The business outgrows the way information used to reach you


Growth changes the organization’s relationship with information.

Leadership moves farther from some parts of the work. Managers become necessary interpreters. Employees become more aware of how speaking may affect relationships and opportunities. Workplace conditions connect across teams that do not always share the same view.


Everything can look fine from the top while something continues to feel off.


That feeling does not prove the organization is unhealthy.

It may simply indicate that leadership no longer has direct access to the information it once received naturally.


The answer is not to assume the worst.

It is to create a reliable way to find out.



Restore the visibility growth made harder to maintain


The Organizational Stability Assessment gives employees a confidential, structured way to identify workplace conditions that may not be reaching leadership clearly. Leadership receives combined findings, business context, and a clearer understanding of where the organization is stable and where attention may be needed.




Sources and Further Reading


Oxford Academic

This study examines how a change in organizational hierarchy affected local information, standardization, and decision outcomes across roughly 2,000 bank branches. The findings also recognize that hierarchy may provide benefits in some environments. [academic.oup.com]


Microsoft Research, Yale University, and RAND Corporation

This research examines communication patterns within and across a large supervisory hierarchy and the role organizational position plays in routine communication. [arxiv.org]


European Journal of Training and Development

This systematic literature review examines the differences between employee silence and organizational silence and considers the contextual, leadership, individual, and organizational factors connected with each. [emerald.com]

Recent Posts

See All
A Stable Result Is Still a Result

Finding little meaningful strain is not an empty outcome. It provides evidence of what is working, what leadership should protect, and whether the organization may qualify for the Redthorne Business S

 
 
 
A Policy Can Exist Without Functioning

A workplace policy only creates value when employees can access it, rely on it, and receive the support it was intended to provide. Formal availability does not always reflect functional reality.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page