top of page

The Cost of Solving the Wrong Problem

May 27
7 min read

Updated: Sep 7

The most expensive workplace solution is not always the one with the highest price. Sometimes it is the one that leaves the original problem in place.


A company sees turnover and increases recognition, leadership sees employees falling behind and adds training, or a team reports communication problems, so the organization purchases another communication platform.

Managers say they need more support, so the company adds staff.


Each response may be reasonable. Each may even improve something.

But if the selected solution does not address the condition producing the problem, the company pays twice.

It pays for the new solution, and it continues paying for the unresolved strain beneath it.


A symptom can point to several different problems


Broad workplace symptoms rarely identify their own cause.

Employees missing deadlines could indicate:


  • Too much work


  • Unclear priorities


  • Frequent interruptions


  • Missing information


  • Delayed approvals


  • Inadequate tools


  • Rework from an earlier process


  • Responsibilities that are poorly defined


  • A schedule that does not provide enough uninterrupted working time


Those conditions may all create a similar visible effect, but they do not require the same response.


Adding staff may help when workload volume genuinely exceeds available capacity. It will not necessarily help when employees spend much of the day waiting for approvals or correcting incomplete work.


Additional training may help when employees lack necessary knowledge. It will not solve a process in which ownership remains unclear.


A new software platform may help when current technology cannot support the work. It may add more friction when the actual problem is missing access, inconsistent expectations, or a workflow that no one has fully defined.


The symptom tells leadership where to look. It does not yet tell leadership what to buy.


Familiar solutions are not always precise solutions


When leadership must respond without enough information, familiar solutions naturally rise to the top.


A communication problem receives a communication tool.


A morale problem receives a recognition program.


A productivity problem receives a performance target.


A retention problem receives a compensation review.


There may be legitimate reasons to choose any of those responses. The risk comes from treating the category as the diagnosis.


“Communication” could mean that employees do not receive information, but it could also mean:


  • Instructions are outdated.


  • Employees do not know who owns the next step.


  • Policies change without a reliable update process.


  • Important files are difficult to access.


  • Another department sends incomplete work.


  • Employees do not feel safe asking for clarification.


  • Managers communicate expectations, but the workload leaves no room to follow them.


Another communication tool only addresses some of those possibilities.

Likewise, a retention problem may involve compensation, but it may also involve scheduling, workload, management practices, role alignment, broken processes, inaccessible benefits, insufficient recovery time, or repeated interference with personal time.

Leadership cannot choose a precise response until the organization understands the condition behind the symptom.


Root cause analysis protects the investment in the solution


The American Society for Quality defines root cause analysis as a group of approaches and techniques used to uncover the underlying causes of problems. ASQ also notes that root cause analysis is part of a larger problem solving process and does not produce improvement by itself. The findings must still lead to an appropriate corrective response. ASQ’s explanation of root cause analysis provides additional context. [asq.org]


That distinction matters. Diagnosis is not the final solution. It is what helps leadership select a solution that matches the problem.

Without that step, an organization may improve something that was never driving the original concern.

With that step, leadership can ask:


  • What specific condition is present?


  • Who is affected by it?


  • What changes in the work when it occurs?


  • How frequently does the effect appear?


  • How broadly is the condition reported?


  • Is it influencing employees’ reasons to stay?


  • What response actually fits the evidence?


The purpose is not to delay action indefinitely. It is to prevent urgency from sending money and effort in the wrong direction.


The original problem does not pause while the new solution is introduced


A mismatched intervention creates more than an unnecessary expense.

It also consumes:


  • Leadership attention


  • Employee time


  • Implementation capacity


  • Training resources


  • Manager participation


  • Internal trust


  • The opportunity to address the actual problem sooner


Consider a company responding to workload complaints by hiring another employee. If the real source of strain is unclear ownership, the new employee enters the same unclear structure. Work may remain unevenly distributed, tasks may continue to be duplicated, and responsibilities may still move toward whichever employee is most likely to catch what others miss.

The company has added payroll without correcting the mechanism producing the workload problem.


Or consider an organization responding to declining morale with a recognition initiative. Recognition may be genuinely appreciated. But if employees are frustrated because schedules change without enough notice, appreciation does not restore predictability. The program and the schedule concern can exist at the same time.

The organization did something positive. It simply did not resolve the condition that required attention.


More effort does not correct a mismatched diagnosis


This is where frustration can become cyclical.

Leadership invests in a solution and expects improvement, employees see the investment but continue experiencing the same daily barrier, and the expected improvement does not appear.


Leadership may conclude that employees are difficult to satisfy, resistant to change, or unwilling to appreciate what the company provides.

Employees may conclude that leadership is not listening or is more interested in visible programs than everyday working conditions.


Neither conclusion necessarily reflects the original intent of either side.

Leadership may have acted sincerely. Employees may appreciate the effort. The problem is that effort and alignment are not the same thing.

A solution can be thoughtful, expensive, and competently implemented while still being unrelated to the root cause.


Research shows why the level of intervention matters


A University of Oxford study examined survey data from 46,336 employees across 233 organizations. The study found no evidence that participants in several common individual level mental health interventions, including mindfulness, resilience training, relaxation classes, and wellbeing apps, reported better subjective wellbeing than nonparticipants. The researcher pointed toward organizational changes involving scheduling, management practices, staffing resources, performance review, and job design as potentially more relevant areas for improving workplace wellbeing. The University of Oxford’s Wellbeing Research Centre explains the study and its limitations. [wellbeing....c.ox.ac.uk]


The study does not prove that every individual wellbeing program is ineffective. It examined particular interventions within a specific dataset, and the findings should not be applied beyond what the research supports.


It does illustrate a broader problem. An intervention directed at the individual may not resolve strain created by the organization’s working conditions.

Helping someone manage pressure is different from identifying why the pressure is recurring.

Giving employees another resource is different from determining whether workload, scheduling, staffing, management practices, or job design are creating the need for relief.

The right solution depends on the source of the problem.


Retention increases the cost of an incorrect response


The consequences may become especially important when the unresolved condition influences retention.

Gallup reported in research updated on February 16, 2026, that 42 percent of employees who voluntarily left an organization during the study period believed their manager or organization could have done something to prevent their departure. Gallup also reported that 77 percent of voluntary leavers either left within three months of beginning a job search or did not actively search before leaving. Gallup’s research on preventable employee turnover is available here. [gallup.com]


That does not mean every resignation can be prevented or that one workplace initiative will preserve every employee. It means the organization may have less time than expected once retention risk becomes visible.

If leadership spends that time addressing a symptom rather than the condition shaping the employee’s decision, the company may lose both the investment in the solution and the opportunity to intervene while the employee is still willing to remain.


The purpose of diagnosis is not to make every solution smaller


Sometimes the evidence supports a substantial investment.

The organization may need to:

  • Increase compensation


  • Add staff


  • Replace unreliable equipment


  • Redesign a role


  • Prepare managers more thoroughly


  • Change scheduling practices


  • Replace a system that no longer supports the work


Redthorne’s position is not that workplace problems are always inexpensive to solve. The value is knowing why the investment is necessary and what it is expected to address. In other cases, the evidence may point to a practical correction involving an existing resource:


  • Give employees the permissions they already need.


  • Define ownership at one recurring handoff.


  • Release schedules earlier.


  • Remove a redundant approval.


  • Update instructions to reflect the current process.


  • Enforce an existing policy consistently.


  • Stop unnecessary requests from reaching employees during protected personal time.


The assessment does not predetermine which type of response is appropriate.

The diagnosis determines where leadership should look.


Find the mechanism before funding the remedy


Workplace symptoms create urgency.

Turnover is expensive. Delays affect clients. Rework consumes capacity. Tension spreads. Reliable employees begin pulling back.


Leadership reasonably wants to respond.

But urgency should not require guesswork.


Before purchasing another platform, adding another program, restructuring another role, or asking employees to adapt again, leadership needs to understand what is actually producing the problem.


The goal is not to discourage investment.

It is to protect the investment by directing it toward the condition that matters.

A company should not have to keep adding solutions while the same underlying strain remains untouched.



Find what deserves attention before choosing the solution


The Organizational Stability Assessment identifies if and where employees are experiencing pain points, traces strain to its root causes, and shows leadership how workplace conditions are affecting work and retention.




Sources and Further Reading


American Society for Quality

ASQ explains the role of root cause analysis in identifying the underlying cause of a problem and connecting the diagnosis with a broader improvement process. [asq.org]


University of Oxford Wellbeing Research Centre

The Oxford summary explains findings from a study of 46,336 employees across 233 organizations and discusses the difference between individual level interventions and organizational working conditions. [wellbeing....c.ox.ac.uk]


Gallup

Gallup examines preventable turnover, how quickly some employees leave once the exit process begins, and how often managers remain unaware of the decision. [gallup.com]

Recent Posts

See All
A Stable Result Is Still a Result

Finding little meaningful strain is not an empty outcome. It provides evidence of what is working, what leadership should protect, and whether the organization may qualify for the Redthorne Business S

 
 
 
Why Growth Makes a Business Harder to Read

As a company grows, information passes through more roles, priorities, and relationships before reaching leadership. The business can outgrow the informal ways its leaders once understood what was hap

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page